CommunitiesColorectal CancerHas anyone refused rectal cancer surgery due to concerns about getting a stoma bag?

Has anyone refused rectal cancer surgery due to concerns about getting a stoma b...

KA

Community Member

5 days ago

Hi, I everyone! So sorry to hear about what you all are going through. Apologies for the length of this!Just diagnosed with rectal cancer after a colonoscopy (& concurrent polypectomy of the huge polyp/tumor found, shown to be cancerous with unclear margins ) which I chose to do on my own, but took a month to schedule with a gastroenterologist! Anyway, I immediately switched to a top surgeon at MSK. After MRI & CT there showed Stage 3, however, (fortunately, CT scans were clear!) the entire team met and offered me 2 options; immediate surgery to remove most of rectum, etc., or waiting 6 weeks for a second MRI to see how much of what was shown could actually be inflammation from the polypectomy. I quickly chose Option 2, which they recommended. Here is my question for all of you: Has anyone refused surgery because they just could not live with an ostomy/illeosomy/etc. involving a bag? This top surgeon says he never does surgery without putting in at least a temporary stoma (and not to trust any surgeon who says he can do this surgery without one.) While that can often be reversed months later, my research shows that's not always the case. If the second MRI does still show the cancer, I am willing to go through chemo, radiation, etc. Not a candidate for immunotherapy, unfortunately. The doctor says they will still treat me even if I refuse surgery. Has anyone else out there chosen this path? Thank you so much for all your help!

5 comments
Comment
CA

Community Member

4 days ago

This is such a difficult situation, and it's completely understandable to have concerns about living with a stoma. Many people in this community have faced similar fears and decisions about rectal cancer treatment options. The good news is that temporary stomas are often successfully reversed, though it's wise to be prepared for all possibilities. Consider connecting with others here who have experience with stomas - many find that their quality of life concerns were greater beforehand than the reality turned out to be. What aspects of this decision are weighing most heavily on your mind right now?

1
JM

Community Member

4 days ago

I was diagnosed 6 years ago with stage 4 colon cancer. I received chemo and radiation. It has not returned to the original site so i opted out of surgery because i did not want a colostomy bag. It has since returned to my lungs and that’s my current battle. I am greatful that i did not get the bag.

1
KA

Community Member

4 days ago

Thank you so much for sharing, Joe! I'm so very sorry that cancer has returned to your lungs. It doesn't seem that surgery would have prevented that, though, six years later? I don't really see how, or understand how they know it's the same cancer -- couldn't it just be a new, unrelated cancer? I am so glad for you that you had those 6 years without a bag, and am wishing you the least painful and most successful treatment for the lung cancer!

RO

Community Member

4 days ago

I cancelled my first surgery date for the colostomy at the last minute. I brought the topic up with my oncologist first and he didn't even comment. Then when I saw the surgical oncologist he jumped on the ID and ran with it scheduling for the next Monday. Didn't have a good feeling about all if it, mainly wanted info about the procedure didn't want to go from frying pan to the fire and two weeks later had the procedure done. For me it was a big mistake as I suffer from a rare neuropathic pain disease complicating everything. There are pros and cons, you need to discuss with someone the pros and cons. Because my tumor who I named George, Mine is a permanent one, even if c they manage to shrink it because it's right on the rectum and sphincter, both internal and external when surgery is done to remove the mass I will no longer have a rectum, it's pushed into the vaginal area as well. You need to get nan honest evaluation, I also have a Foley, double nuisance.

JB

Community Member

2 days ago

I chosen the bag after chemo and had it for 3 months ,it’s definitely a challenge but it’s manageable compared to not being alive , Just manage what you eat not too much I never had a bag explode but close to it and I worked on my off week from chemo so you can do this if it’s going to help you ,stay strong you got this

0

New to the community?

Create an account to connect with others navigating cancer.

Outcomes4Me

© 2026 Outcomes4Me Inc. All rights reserved.