Community Member
2 years agoAfter a biopsy in August, I was diagnosed with Invasive Ductal Carcinoma. Estrogen, progesterone, and HER2 positive (score of 3). I had a double mastectomy in October, and the pathology came back estrogen and progesterone positive, and HER2 negative (score of 1). ?!?! The surgeon was surprised, so she sent it off again, and the HER2 scored a 2 (borderline)! I’m so confused. The tumor/tissue was tested three times and I received THREE different results. Has this happened to anyone else?
Accepted Answer
This kind of variation in HER2 testing results can definitely happen and understandably creates confusion during an already stressful time. Testing differences can occur due to various factors including tissue preservation, lab processing methods, or even differences between the original tumor and surrounding tissue. Many patients in this community have shared similar experiences with changing test results, so you're not alone in facing this uncertainty. Your medical team will likely use all the available information to determine the best treatment approach moving forward.
3+ patients found this helpful
Community Member
6 months agoYes, my surgical path came back HER2 negative actually. My progesterone was much different too. It's my understanding from reading research that the cancer cells can be very different, referred to formally as heterogeneous. It's the nature of this breast cancer beast we are living with. My treatment continues to be based on my original biopsy (triple positive, 2.2cm, node negative) Since I had residual tumor, I did TDM1 for 14 cycles after my chemo and right mastectomy.
Community Member
2 months agoThis kind of variation in HER2 testing results can definitely happen and understandably creates confusion during an already stressful time. Testing differences can occur due to various factors including tissue preservation, lab processing methods, or even differences between the original tumor and surrounding tissue. Many patients in this community have shared similar experiences with changing test results, so you're not alone in facing this uncertainty. Your medical team will likely use all the available information to determine the best treatment approach moving forward.
New to the community?
Create an account to connect with others navigating cancer.
© 2025 Outcomes4Me Inc. All rights reserved.