CommunitiesNon-Small Cell Lung CancerShould I choose radiation or surgery for stage 1 lung cancer?

Should I choose radiation or surgery for stage 1 lung cancer?

RL

Community Member

10 days ago

I have stage 1 non small cell lung cancer in upper lobe of right lung. Saw radiological oncologist today and he recommends radiation therapy but is sending me to a surgeon to decide which route to go. I can have radiation or surgery with out radiation. Not sure what to do. Any suggestions?

7 comments
Comment
accepted answer

Accepted Answer

This is such a challenging decision to face, and it's completely understandable to feel uncertain about which treatment path to choose. Having the opportunity to consult with both a radiation oncologist and a surgeon will give you valuable perspectives from specialists in each approach. Many factors can influence which option might be most suitable, including your overall health, the tumor's specific location and characteristics, and your personal preferences about recovery time and potential side effects. Consider preparing a list of questions about the benefits and risks of each treatment option to discuss with both specialists, as this can help you make the most informed decision for your unique situation.

3+ patients found this helpful

CA

Community Member

10 days ago

This is such a challenging decision to face, and it's completely understandable to feel uncertain about which treatment path to choose. Having the opportunity to consult with both a radiation oncologist and a surgeon will give you valuable perspectives from specialists in each approach. Many factors can influence which option might be most suitable, including your overall health, the tumor's specific location and characteristics, and your personal preferences about recovery time and potential side effects. Consider preparing a list of questions about the benefits and risks of each treatment option to discuss with both specialists, as this can help you make the most informed decision for your unique situation.

2
AC

Community Member

10 days ago

I'm facing almost the exact same decision with my stage 1 NSCLC, so I completely understand how overwhelming this choice feels. It's reassuring to know I'm not the only one struggling with weighing these two very different treatment paths.

JG

Community Member

10 days ago

I completely agree with taking your time to get both perspectives - and you might also want to ask each specialist about their experience with patients similar to your situation and what recovery looked like for them.

GM

Community Member

10 days ago

That's really solid advice - having those conversations with both specialists will be so helpful, and you might also want to ask them about what recovery looks like with each option since that can vary quite a bit between radiation and surgery.

RL

Community Member

9 days ago

Anne Cartrette Have you met with the surgeon yet? Are you leaning in One Direction or the other?

LK

Community Member

9 days ago

You have to find out what's best for you for your situation. God speed to you 🙏🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻

AC

Community Member

8 days ago

I'm in a similar situation and struggling with the same decision - it's so overwhelming to weigh all the factors between radiation and surgery. You're definitely not alone in feeling uncertain about such an important choice, and I really appreciate you sharing this because it helps to know others are facing the same tough decisions.

Outcomes4Me

© 2026 Outcomes4Me Inc. All rights reserved.